In chamber and solo works, Bronfman’s artistry at its height

Following two performances of Brahms’ Piano Concerto No. 2, Yefim Bronfman’s …

With season opener, Seraphic Fire hears America singing

Patrick Quigley can usually be counted on to take the route …

Bronfman offers powerful Brahms with MTT, New World Symphony

During the late 19th century, Wagner and Brahms were considered philosophical …


Festival Miami to lead off with music made in America

The American composer Paul Creston showed fine penmanship in writing down …

Powered by WP Bannerize


MTT explains incident, said he didn’t oust woman from New World concert 

Thu Oct 23, 2014 at 11:23 am

By Lawrence A. Johnson

MIchael Tilson Thomas

MIchael Tilson Thomas

Michael Tilson Thomas explained his actions last week, which resulted in a woman and her daughter leaving the hall in mid-performance of a New World Symphony concert.

The conductor said that he was trying to prevent the performance of Brahms’ Piano Concerto No. 2 with Yefim Bronfman last Friday at New World Center from being disrupted. A woman was sitting with her nine-year-old daughter directly in his line of vision and, he said, the girl was jumping about during the performance of Dawn and Siegfried’s Rhine Journey by Wagner on the first half, which was led by NWS conducting fellow Christian Reif. He said he was worried that the quiet lyricism of the Brahms concerto’s third movement would be broken up by the girl’s jumpiness.

“The little girl was restless and moving around and I was just afraid what would happen in the Adagio,” said the conductor in a phone call on Wednesday. “Our cellist Rosanna Butterfield had worked so hard all week on her solo. I just didn’t want to see it ruined.”

He said rather than take a chance, between the second and third movements he asked the woman to move to a different seat. He emphasized that he never asked her to leave the concert.

“It’s one of those situations when you have to make a decision quickly. I made the call to ask her to move—which I did quietly and courteously. I was surprised when she left the hall.”

While not apologizing for his actions, the conductor clearly regretted the incident, which went viral on the internet after South Florida Classical Review broke the story Wednesday morning.

“I felt so bad when this whole thing happened,” he added. “It was just one of those lamentable situations that can occur sometimes. How do you communicate with people [in a concert situation]? I hope she’ll come back.”

In a written statement released later in the day by his management and the New World Symphony, Tilson Thomas said, “I felt responsible to ensure that there would be a calm and quiet atmosphere, both for the cello soloist playing the piece for the first time, and for the audience. I quietly asked the woman if she would mind moving to some seats on one side or the other of the section in which she was seated. To my surprise, she left the auditorium, which was not at all my intention. The performance then continued and Rosanna Butterfield, one of our cello Fellows, played with radiant musicality.

“Throughout my life I have encouraged families and young people to attend concerts. I know that the New World Symphony staff has been in conversation with the mother to explore the situation.  I hope very much that they will come back.”

Craig Hall, New World Symphony’s vice-president for communications, confirmed that the orchestra management had met with the mother and daughter and “discussed the misunderstanding.” He said that the family would be attending next week’s New World Symphony concert.

Posted in News
No Comments

Coming Up

October 24

Dranoff International 2 Piano Foundation
Olha Chipak & Oleksiy Kushnir, duo-pianists…


New World Symphony mum on MTT’s eviction of audience member during concert

Last week’s New World Symphony performance of Brahms’ Piano Concerto No. …

Powered by WP Bannerize