Performances

Intrusive ghost apart, singers deliver impressive vocalism in FGO’s “Lucia”

Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor is one of the great bel canto […]

New World Symphony, Master Chorale join forces for Mozart Requiem

For its first downtown Arsht Center program this season, the New […]

Inanga & Omordia help Dranoff celebrate 40 years of 2 Piano advocacy

Four decades ago, pianist and educator Loretta Dranoff founded a two […]


Articles

James Bass set to make his mark as new leader of Seraphic Fire

When James K. Bass takes the stage this week for his […]


Concert review

Thibaudet provides the fireworks in Palm Beach Symphony opener

Wed Nov 18, 2026 at 1:32 pm

By David Fleshler

Jean-Yves Thibaudet performed Saint-Saëns’ Piano Concerto No. 5 “Egyptian” with the Palm Beach Symphony led by Gerard Schwarz Tuesday night at the Kravis Center.

From just a glance at the program, the Palm Beach Symphony’s opening concert would appear to be an exemplary way to start the season.

The concert included a world premiere, an event that has become routine under the leadership of music director Gerard Schwarz. It included a performance by the renowned pianist Jean-Yves Thibaudet of Saint-Saëns’ Piano Concerto No. 5, a neglected work that’s so brilliant and tuneful that it’s easy to appreciate on first hearing. And there was a classic, the Brahms Symphony No. 4, the composer’s darkest symphony.

At the beginning, the audience rose for the traditional season-opening performance of The Star-Spangled Banner, conducted by Joseph Kasputys, who won the right to lead the anthem in an auction at the orchestra’s annual gala.

The world premiere was Consolation by the American composer Daron Aric Hagen, who came on stage and spoke a few words before the performance. 

Composed in honor of a friend from the Curtis Institute of Music, the violinist Michaela Paetsch who died in 2023, the brief piece did a lot in a few minutes. Oboes and high violins dominated the texture, with ascending melodies and delicate, shimmering dissonances within a tonal harmonic vocabulary. Even without knowing the work’s inspiration, it would have been possible to hear the warmth, yearning and sadness in its radiant few minutes of music.

Another brief work by Hagen followed, con gái, adapted from his opera Amelia. Aggressive and brassy from the opening, with wild string passages, it contrasted sharply with the previous work, then calmed toward the end.

The piano concerto, known as the “Egyptian” and written while Saint-Saëns vacationed in the temple city of Luxor, was given its premiere in 1896 with the composer himself at the keyboard. Thibaudet gave a performance on a grand scale, with sweeping melodies, sensitive phrasing and keyboard-pounding bravura.

Although the piece is a virtuoso barnburner of a concerto, it’s full of delicate passages, such as the sensual second theme of the opening Allegro, to which Thibaudet brought an ardent, singing quality. And there were intricate sections in which the pianist played an elaborate filigree of notes to accompany melodies in the orchestra; here Thibaudet brought precision and sharp articulation that penetrated the massed orchestra forces. The orchestra under Schwarz didn’t quite match Thibaudet’s sweep and verve, and there were times when the performance would have been better served by the ensemble taking center stage. 

The Andante is not a conventional slow movement but rather propulsive and energetic. This movement contains the most obviously “Egyptian” components of the concerto, with Middle Eastern-sounding turns of phrase. Thibaudet drew unearthly sounds from the piano, in quirky melodies and wisps of runs that evoked a European’s impressions of the mysterious East.

Thibaudet attacked the last movement with aggressiveness, playing the virtuoso passages at high speed and volume, and bringing grace and elegance to the movement’s main theme. 

His encore couldn’t have contrasted more with the flashy concerto, a performance of quiet nobility of the Brahms Intermezzo Op. 118, no. 2.

After intermission, the orchestra turned to the Brahms symphony, giving a mixed performance in which the best playing came in the last movement. In the opening and throughout the first movement, string textures were thin. Despite vigorous horn playing – which was a highlight through the symphony – and warmth in the winds, the movement felt subdued and short on drama. 

The Andante came off better, with warm, balanced textures in winds and a surging crescendo toward the end. The orchestra brought dynamism and tight ensemble precision to the lively Allegro giocoso.

The concluding Allegro is one of Brahms’ most striking symphonic movements, a grim passacaglia, a form based on a repeated harmonic sequence, in which the historically minded composer seemed to distill two centuries of musical knowledge. At the opening, Schwarz stood motionless on the podium, waiting until the hall was completely silent before summoning up the stark brass chords that stated the theme.

From there, the movement proceeded with relentless drive, with the drama and rhythmic pulse present even in moments of apparent calm. Violins played with sweep and power in a melody that began on their lowest string. 

The flute solo by Nadine Asin, was tonally rich and phrased with a dramatic arc, bringing tension and suspense to this passage despite the spare orchestral forces involved. The restatement of the main theme, with the turbulent passages that followed, brought the work to a rumbling, impassioned conclusion. 

The Palm Beach Symphony’s next concert will take place 7:30 p.m. Dec. 16. The program includes Shostakovich’s Symphony No. 6, selections from Handel’s Messiah and Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 3 with soloist Yefim Bronfman. palmbeachsymphony.org

 

Sent from my iPhone

Posted in Performances
No Comments

Coming Up

November 19

Seraphic Fire
James K. Bass, conductor
“Blue Notes”
[…]


News

Maria Todaro is working to tie FGO’s rebirth to Miami’s ascendancy

“Florida Grand Opera should be the pride of South Florida,” proclaims […]